Site & dates
Street of the Knights (Odos Ippoton), Collachium › between the Inn of France and the Inn of England
The Inn (Auberge) of Italy — in Greek, το Κατάλυμα της Ιταλίας — stands on the Street of the Knights at the heart of the Collachium, near the old Hospital of the Knights and the church of Our Lady of the Castle. It bears, above its portal, the quartered coat of arms of Grand Master Fabrizio del Carretto and the date 1519, and stood, on the archival evidence assembled by Patrice Foutakis (2020), on or immediately beside land previously occupied by del Carretto's own mansion house during his term as admiral of the Order, 1509–1513. Comparatively small beside its neighbours, it is, in Foutakis's own assessment, one of the best-preserved and most completely legible auberges on the street.
A Grand Master's arms on a Tongue's auberge
Gerola and Gabriel’s doubts › Maiuri’s and Foutakis’s answers
Unlike several of the Order's other Rhodian auberges, this building's identification as the Inn of the Tongue of Italy did not go unquestioned. Two of the twentieth century's most careful students of the medieval town doubted it, principally on the grounds that a communal Inn ought properly to bear the arms of the Tongue itself, or of its senior officer, rather than a Grand Master's personal arms. This project reports that historiographical debate honestly, together with the archival evidence that has been read as resolving it in the building's favour.
A compact Gothic auberge
Portal, courtyard and well › one of the street’s smallest Inns
A small ogee-arched portal, framed by sculpted decoration and surmounted by Fabrizio del Carretto's coat of arms and the date 1519, leads into a vaulted passage and a small internal courtyard with a well. Built of local Rhodian sandstone in the same idiom as the Order's other Rhodian auberges, the building stands at a notably smaller scale than the Inns of France or Spain — a difference itself central to the modern identity debate discussed above.
1509–1948
From an admiral’s mansion › to Hellenic state property
The Inn of Italy's documented history opens with Fabrizio del Carretto's tenure as admiral, runs through his mastership and the building's construction in 1519, and continues through the Order's final siege, four centuries of Ottoman-period conversion, and a twentieth-century restoration that returned the façade to a legible medieval form.
Eye witness: two doubts and two answers
1912–2020 › a century of scholarly argument over one small façade
Albert Gabriel's own verdict, doubting the building's identification as the communal Inn of the Tongue of Italy, and proposing instead that it was either del Carretto's purely private house or a structure shared between several Tongues.
Answering Gerola directly, Amedeo Maiuri argued that the office of admiral was important enough to warrant its own separate residence distinct from the Tongue's communal Inn, so that a Grand Master's personal arms as former admiral, rather than the Tongue's own arms, were unremarkable on this particular building.
Patrice Foutakis's considered verdict, after assembling five independent eyewitness illustrations of the coat of arms spanning nearly a century together with archival and metrological evidence: the doubts raised by Gerola and Gabriel over the building's identity do not hold up.
Because, being a comparatively small building, it suffered fewer deformations and destructions than the street's larger auberges, the Inn of Italy preserves — in Foutakis's own words — a beautiful architectural unity that distinguishes it as an authentic model and an almost complete house from the beginning of the sixteenth century.
Four scenes from a contested house
1519–1916 › a narrative reconstruction for visitors
A dramatised account, written for visitor interpretation and drawing on the building's own fabric and documented archival record (see History and Testimony, above). It is a narrative device, not a literal historical record.
Fabrizio del Carretto, Grand Master now these six years, walks the short distance from the Palace to the plot he once held as admiral. The masons have finished the ogee frame above the new portal; within the week his own quartered arms — the Order's cross, his family's five cottises — will be set above it, with the year cut plainly beside them. He has fortified half the city already against the guns everyone now builds. This is a smaller kind of building, for a smaller kind of memory.
The Italian scholar stands before the shield, notebook in hand, and frowns. An eagle, quartered, crowned — but whose? Not the Tongue's own arms, as the neighbouring auberges properly show, but a Grand Master's personal device. He writes down his objection carefully: a communal Inn should bear a communal coat of arms. It will take Amedeo Maiuri, rebuilding this very façade three years later, to answer him — and more than a century after that, Patrice Foutakis, to settle the matter for good.
At the platform named for his own Tongue, Andelot Gentili watches the Ottoman guns range in, as they have done at England's bastion and Spain's and Provence's these past weeks. Somewhere behind the lines, the engineer Martinengo who raised these very ramparts lies blinded in one eye, struck at the bastion next door; the Grand Master himself has taken over that post. Gentili's own wall holds a little longer. It will not be enough, in the end — but not for want of what this Tongue built, brick and gun-loop, in its last Rhodian year of peace.
The old plaster has been down a year now, and underneath it, exactly where Witdoeck drew it in 1826, is the scar where a coat of arms once was — and, cut carelessly through one corner of that same scar, a window some Ottoman-period tenant needed more than he needed history. No original shield can be found. Maiuri chooses the plainest of the five conflicting versions his sources give him: an uncrowned eagle, no flamboyant frame, no initials. “So that the restoration of this building,” he will write, “could come to an end as soon as possible.” The marble goes up white against the old grey stone. It is still there today.
Photo gallery
Fifteen views › the Inn of Italy, its heraldry, its fabric, and its life today
Significance criteria
Nine-criteria framework › International importance
Statement of significance
“An authentic model... for the knights of Saint John of Jerusalem.” (Patrice Foutakis's own assessment of the Inn of Italy's preserved architectural unity, 2020.)
Italy held the admiralty, and the pairing reflects a genuine comparative advantage: Genoese, Venetian and southern Italian seafaring experience gave the Tongue's knights a command of naval affairs the Order could not easily have replicated elsewhere — a comparative advantage documented, well before Rhodes, in the Order's own twelfth- and thirteenth-century dependence on Genoese, Pisan and Venetian shipping and notarial record-keeping in the Latin Kingdom of Jerusalem and Cyprus. The galley fleet the admiral commanded was the single capability on which Rhodes's security, its revenue from control of Aegean shipping, and its corsairing income against Muslim vessels all depended.
The Hospitaller Inn of Italy matters not chiefly for its scale — by common consent among the scholars who have studied it, one of the smallest and least architecturally prestigious auberges of the Street of the Knights — but for what it represents: the Tongue of Italy's unique institutional privilege, among the Order's eight national Tongues, of furnishing the admiral who commanded the Order's entire galley fleet, and the direct engagement of successive Italian Grand Masters in building and defending the Hospitaller state at its most critical hour. Giovanni Battista Orsini (1467–1476) and, above all, Fabrizio del Carretto (1509–1513 as admiral, 1513–1521 as Grand Master) exercised that governance at the summit of the Order's institutions, del Carretto engaging Italian Renaissance military engineers to rebuild Rhodes's fortifications against the newly developed heavy gunpowder artillery in the very years he also built this Inn, in 1519.
The building's significance is compounded by a genuinely modern dimension: its very identity as the Tongue of Italy's auberge was disputed in the early twentieth century by the archaeologists Giuseppe Gerola and Albert Gabriel, and defended by Amedeo Maiuri, who restored its façade in 1915–16. Patrice Foutakis's 2020 study, assembling five independent eyewitness illustrations of the coat of arms spanning nearly a century together with archival and metrological evidence, concludes that the doubts raised by Gerola and Gabriel “are not well founded” — a resolution this document reports, together with the debate itself, as part of the monument's own history.
Taken together, the Tongue of Italy's unique hold on the Order's admiralty, the direct personal contribution of Grand Masters Orsini and del Carretto and of the engineer Martinengo to the defence of Rhodes, the bastion of Italy's own place in the siege of 1522, and the building's status as a rare, well-documented case study in the authentication of contested heritage attributions together give the Inn of Italy significance of International importance, as one of the more historically and institutionally consequential — if physically modest — monuments of the UNESCO-inscribed Medieval City of Rhodes.
Hellenic Republic: ΥΑ 23084/737/25-8-1948 — ΦΕΚ 10/23-9-1948 (Ministerial Decision declaring the monuments of the Medieval Town of Rhodes, including the Street of the Knights and its Inns, protected under Greek Archaeological Law), subsequently confirmed under Law 3028/2002 on the Protection of Antiquities and Cultural Heritage in General.
World Heritage property: Medieval City of Rhodes (ref. 493), inscribed 1988, meeting criteria (ii), (iv) and (v). The Inn of Italy, together with the Street of the Knights and the wider circuit of the city walls, is a contributing component of the property.
References
- Brodman, James W. “Rule and Identity: The Case of the Military Orders.” The Catholic Historical Review 87, no. 3 (July 2001): 383–400.
- Bronstein, Judith. “The Hospitallers: From Land to Sea — An Examination of the Hospitallers’ Naval Activities in the Twelfth and Thirteenth Centuries.” The Medieval History Journal 22, no. 1 (2019): 53–91. Principal source for this document’s account of the Order’s pre-Rhodes maritime activity in the Latin Kingdom of Jerusalem, Cilician Armenia and Cyprus, and its use of Genoese, Pisan and Venetian ports and trading privileges.
- Brummett, Palmira. “The Overrated Adversary: Rhodes and Ottoman Naval Power.” The Historical Journal 36, no. 3 (September 1993): 517–541.
- Foutakis, Patrice. “The Inn of the Tongue of Italy for the Hospitaller Knights in Rhodes.” Post-Medieval Archaeology 54, no. 1 (2020): 94–116. DOI: 10.1080/00794236.2020.1750152. Principal source for this document’s account of the building’s identification, architectural and archival history, coat of arms, and the 1915–16 and 1931 interventions; this document notes that Foutakis’s claim of nine successive Piossasco-family admirals (1417–1531) could not be independently verified beyond two named holders using the sources available to this project.
- Gabriel, Albert. La cité de Rhodes: MCCCX–MDXXII, architecture civile et religieuse. Paris: de Boccard, 1923. Cited via Foutakis 2020 for the building’s architectural reconstruction and the doubts raised over its identification.
- Gerola, Giuseppe. “I monumenti medioevali delle Tredici Sporadi.” In Annuario della Regia Scuola archeologica di Atene e delle missioni italiane in Oriente, vol. 1, 169–356. Bergamo: Istituto italiano d’arti grafiche, 1914. Cited via Foutakis 2020 for the doubts raised over the Inn of Italy’s identification.
- Hellenic Government Gazette (ΦΕΚ). Ministerial Decision 23084/737 (25 August 1948), ΦΕΚ 10 (23 September 1948), protection of the monuments of the Medieval Town of Rhodes; Law 3028/2002 on the Protection of Antiquities and Cultural Heritage in General.
- Herzfeld, Michael. “New Light on the 1480 Siege of Rhodes.” The British Museum Quarterly 36, no. 3/4 (Autumn 1972): 69–73.
- ICOMOS Australia. The Burra Charter: The Australia ICOMOS Charter for Places of Cultural Significance. Burwood: ICOMOS Australia, 2013.
- ICOMOS. International Charter for the Conservation and Restoration of Monuments and Sites (the Venice Charter), 1964. General conservation framework applicable to the Medieval City of Rhodes.
- Jacoby, David. “Hospitaller Ships and Transportation across the Mediterranean.” Chapter 6 in The Hospitallers, the Mediterranean and Europe: Festschrift for Anthony Luttrell, edited by Karl Borchardt, Nikolas Jaspert and Helen J. Nicholson, 57–72. Aldershot: Ashgate, 2007. Source for the 1156 and 1161 Genoese records of early Hospitaller shipping and for the Order’s Marseilles–Acre shipping network.
- Kollias, Elias. “The Medieval Town of Rhodes and the Palace of the Grand Master.” Ekdotiki Athinon, Athens, 1994.
- Luttrell, Anthony. “Feudal Tenure and Latin Colonization at Rhodes: 1306–1415.” The English Historical Review 85, no. 337 (October 1970): 755–775.
- Luttrell, Anthony. “The Hospitallers and Concepts of Island Existence.” In Islands and Military Orders, c. 1291–c. 1798, edited by Emanuel Buttigieg and Simon Phillips, 11–18. Farnham: Ashgate, 2013.
- Luttrell, Anthony. “Intrigue, Schism, and Violence among the Hospitallers of Rhodes: 1377–1384.” Speculum 41, no. 1 (January 1966): 30–48.
- Luttrell, A. The Town of Rhodes: 1306–1356. Rhodes: Archaeological Receipts Fund, 2003.
- Luttrell, Anthony. “Venice and the Knights Hospitallers of Rhodes in the Fourteenth Century.” Papers of the British School at Rome 26 (1958): 195–212.
- Maiuri, Amedeo. “Il restauro dell’Albergo d’Italia.” Bolletino d’Arte 10 (1916): 129–43. Contemporary account of the 1915–16 restoration and rebuttal of Gerola’s doubts, cited via Foutakis 2020.
- Miller, Timothy S. “The Knights of Saint John and the Hospitals of the Latin West.” Speculum 53, no. 4 (October 1978): 709–733.
- Papathanasiou-Zuhrt, D. 2017, ‘The United States of Europe. Dress Rehearsal: Rhodes 1306-1522’, in EUROTHENTICA, Apple Books, Cupertino, ISBN 9788890859267.
- Papathanasiou-Zuhrt, D., and Cinar, K. 2023, “Developing a prototype for serious games at places of cultural significance: evidence from UNESCO-listed heritage in Greece and Turkey” in “HERiPRENEURSHIP. Sustainable Tourism, Heritage Management and the Cultural and Creative Industries: Creating New Investment Opportunities at Places of Cultural Significance”, pp. 197-208, ISBN 978 606 020 654 5.
- Papathanasiou-Zuhrt, D., Di Russo, A., and Weiss-Ibanez, D. A. “The Gamification of Heritage in the Unesco Listed Medieval City of Rhodes.” In Gamifin Conference 2017, Pori, Finland, 9-10 May 2017, University Consortium Pori, 2017.
- Papathanasiou-Zuhrt, D., Stavrinoudis, Th., Glyptou, K., and Skoultsos, S. “QR-Rhodes: From the Time Machine to the QR Code. Play Rooms for Non-Captive Audiences in the Age of Mobile Telephony. The Approach of the SEE TCP SAGITTARIUS 2011-2014.” Paper presented at the 5th International Scientific Conference “Tourism Trends and Advances in the 21st Century”, 30 May–2 June 2013.
- Phillips, Simon. “The Hospitallers’ Acquisition of the Templar Lands in England.” In The Debate on the Trial of the Templars (1307–1314), edited by Jochen Burgtorf, Paul F. Crawford, and Helen J. Nicholson, 233–246. Aldershot: Ashgate, 2010.
- Phillips, Simon. “The Hospitallers’ Aegean Empire in the Late Fifteenth Century: The Contribution of Cyprus in the Struggle for Supremacy.” In The Struggle for Supremacy: The Mediterranean World in 1453 and Beyond, edited by George Cassar, Dane Munro, and Noel Buttigieg, 23–30. Valletta: Sacra Militia Foundation, 2019.
- Phillips, Simon. Rhodes in the Final Hospitaller Years, 1502–1521: Latin and Greek Interaction in the Aegean and Eastern Mediterranean. PhD diss., National and Kapodistrian University of Athens, 2021.
- REBOOT Statement of Significance: Admiralty of the Knights Hospitallers, Rhodes (2026) — cross-referenced for the Order’s admirals of the Italian Tongue, including the correction of an overclaim about nine successive Piossasco-family admirals.
- REBOOT Statement of Significance: Castellania, Rhodes (2026) — cross-referenced for the 1449 investigation of Admiral Fantino Quirini.
- REBOOT Statement of Significance: Fort St Nicholas, Rhodes (2026) — cross-referenced for the 1480 and 1522 sieges.
- REBOOT Statement of Significance: House of Prince Cem, Rhodes (2026) — cross-referenced for the Order’s history at Rhodes and its Grand Masters.
- REBOOT Statement of Significance: Porta Marina, Rhodes (2026) — cross-referenced for the 1480 siege and Pierre d’Aubusson.
- REBOOT Statement of Significance: Street of the Knights, Rhodes (2026) — cross-referenced for the Order’s Langue and governance system generally.
- Rottiers, Bernard Eugène Antoine. Description des monumens de Rhodes. Brussels: A. Colinez, 1830. Earliest published depiction of the building’s coat of arms (from Witdoeck’s 1826 lithograph), cited via Foutakis 2020.
- Setton, Kenneth M. The Papacy and the Levant, 1204–1571, Vol. I: The Thirteenth and Fourteenth Centuries. Philadelphia: American Philosophical Society, 1976. [The sole source consulted for this document cites this series as its “Fifteenth Century” volume; the volume title is reported here as supplied.]
- Setton, Kenneth M. The Papacy and the Levant, 1204–1571, Vol. III: The Sixteenth Century to the Reign of Julius III. Philadelphia: American Philosophical Society, 1976.
- Soldani, Maria Elisa, and Daniel Duran i Duelt. “Religion, Warfare and Business in Fifteenth-Century Rhodes.” In Religione e istituzioni religiose nell’economia europea, 1000–1800 / Religion and Religious Institutions in the European Economy, 1000–1800, edited by Francesco Ammannati, 257–270. Florence: Firenze University Press, 2012.
- Soucek, Svatopluk. “Naval Aspects of the Ottoman Conquests of Rhodes, Cyprus and Crete.” Studia Islamica, no. 98/99 (2004): 219–261.
- UNESCO World Heritage Centre. “Medieval City of Rhodes.” World Heritage List, ref. 493. Inscribed 1988. https://whc.unesco.org/en/list/493.
- Valkana, A. The Knights of Rhodes. Athens: M. Toubis, 2012.
- Vertot, René Aubert, Abbé de. The History of the Knights Hospitallers of St. John of Jerusalem. 5 vols. Edinburgh: R. Fleming, 1757. Vol. III (Books VII–IX) — cross-referenced for the masterships of Giovanni Battista Orsini and Fabrizio del Carretto, the recruitment of Gabriele Martinengo, and the defence of the bastion of Italy in the siege of 1522.